Balochistan: Another Perspective

28 Apr

The following article is a guest post authored by prominent Baloch nationalist Akhtar Mengal’s daughter. I am merely publishing it and cannot take credit for any of the writing. There have been no content cuts and the piece is presented in its entirety. The purpose behind posting this piece is to honour the lives and memories of those who have been silenced over Balochistan, from Sabeen to my brothers and sisters in Balochistan and my soldiers. It is time we talk and talk openly. 

Balochistan: Another Perspective

What concerns me is a word. It is a word that is not often heard on the lips of people in most parts of the world but for me it is a word that dearly needs to be spoken; it is a word that whenever I do hear it said, or say it myself, it stirs emotions that when I try to explain, I cannot do justice to the memories they evoke. That word is Balochistan.

I have grown up around politics and in politics. For a daughter of a Baloch tribal leader and activist, politics and life are irreversibly intertwined. The need to understand the ethnic and national tensions that have plagued Pakistani society for decades is integral to how I think, and as important as the lives—and deaths—of family to these struggles. To understand what drives individuals, tribes and nations to do what they do is a necessity. Although many people are unaware of this, there has been resistance from the Baloch people to Balochistan’s inclusion in the Pakistani state since its forced annexation in 1947, when Pakistan state separated from India at Partition. The Baloch people have always viewed Balochistan as a proudly independent nation, asserting their right to self-determination and the right to pursue their own wishes in their own way; to exploit their own huge mineral wealth without it being devoured by companies owned and run by the Pakistani elite that make up the Islamabad government and the military that underpins its pre-eminence. The tribal system in Balochistan has been strongly held culpable for Balochistan’s impoverishment. Ironically most of the Baloch tribal deities serve the government.

My grandfather, Sardar Attaullah Mengal joined politics as an activist member of the Baloch movement. When my grandfather was chosen as a Sardar by the Mengal tribe, the government nominated his uncle to create a dispute within the family over the throne. The Mengal tribe did not accept the government’s decision and ended up killing my grandfather’s uncle. Subsequently, my grandfather was arrested along with his brother, father and 300 tribal people for five years. He served as the first Chief minister of Balochistan and it was during his rule when the first university in Balochistan opened. Years have passed, governments have changed but the number of universities has not. He spent years in jail only because he stood up against the tyranny that prevailed in Balochistan. It was during his revolt when his family was made a target.

My uncle, Shaheed Asadullah Mengal was the first case of a missing person in Balochistan in 1974 during Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto’s regime. His death was never believed amongst our family members as no evidence, associated to his death, was found. There was always a ray of hope of his return; a hope which died the day my grandfather named my cousin after him. That’s when everyone knew Shaheed Asadullah Mengal, who was only 19 years old at that time of his disappearance, was gone.

My maternal grandfather, Shaheed Aslam Jan Gichki, another advocate of freedom for the Baloch people, was murdered in 2002. Following his death, politics assumed new and frightening proportions. Our family was not only divided but hatred amongst us elevated for one another. A tactic (‘divide and rule’) I strong believe the British left for our agencies to adapt. Even though his murder is assumed to be the cause of tribal enmity, the ones who are aware of deceitful Pakistan politics know who is responsible for his death. The torment imposed on my family and the Baloch people, initially created a feeling of vulnerability, however, as the atrocities within Pakistani society increased, my desire to find out why these things were happening, and to do something to combat them, increased.  Our wounds had still not been healed when my uncle Shaheed Hasan Gichki was brutally murdered in Central Jail Karachi in 2006. Not only was he a father figure to us but a man with utmost dignity.

During Pervez Musharaf’s establishment, my father had become extremely vocal in Balochistan and instigated a wake up call for the Baloch people. To begin a hindrance to his cause, the agencies’ new targets were Akhtar Mengal’s children. My siblings and I were constantly being followed to school. This was the reason why he left everything behind, only to be trapped in a game he did not know was being played. He was arrested as a consequence of “harassing” intelligence militia. Agencies and police surrounded our house in Karachi, as if the leading terrorist resided there. My father was released after the PPP came into power. Luckily he was not killed or tortured in jail but was kept in solitary confinement. Unluckily, his food poisoned to such an extent where that he suffers to this day.

After moving to Dubai in self-exile, we thought things might get better but they never did. Countless from the Balochistan National Party’s central workers were openly murdered on the streets. Shaheed Hassan Gichki’s father, Shaheed Nadir Gichki was murdered in Tump by government authorities. My cousins, Shaheed Murad Gichki and Shaheed Zubair Gichki, were brutally murdered in Turbat. Many young Baloch brothers have gone missing. Many bullet-riddled bodies found. Yet no one hears our cry. We pleaded, knocked every door there is in the name of justice. What have we got from the people of Pakistan except neglect and torment?

The ones who are brave enough to stand beside us and support our cause are made a target. Sabeen Mahmud was a fearless activist who not only stood up for what she believed but left a message most of the intellectuals should make use of. If we, the Baloch were ever considered a part of Pakistan, Sabeen would not be the only one debating. The issue of missing persons has become a forbidden topic of discussion in Pakistan. If scrutinised closely one can question what information is being hidden from the mainstream media? A question when people like Sabeen and Hamid Mir tried to challenge received bullets as an answer.

There is a growing and pressing need to come to terms with the issues of Balochistan so that we can calmly and peacefully address what really matters: the well-being of all people and how to make sure that repression and reprisal is turned into liberation, mutual dependence and cooperation. It is only through the means of political discourse and agreement between willing partners that this can be achieved The state, with its immense resources (many of which are, ironically, from Baloch sources) and institutions is encouraging disorder, disunity and fragmentation in Baloch society. They use all possible resources to discourage any political and social opposition in the province—even those that are illegal and are opposed by western governments and human rights bodies. Both ‘Pro-government’ and nationalist tribal leaders blame each other as the cause of the problem, and as ultimately taking advantage of their power base for their own selfish ends. This, rather than working together for the betterment of Balochistan and its people.

Fragmentation and disorder in Balochistan has badly affected the political and social process. Disunity among both tribal chiefs and moderate political elements has encouraged the authorities to increase the ferocity of the promotion of their agenda with support garnered by military and the intelligence agencies. Baloch society, with its low literacy rate, minimal communication resources and worsening social indicators, ironically is awash with natural resources and has a vital strategic importance as it borders the conflict hotspots of Iran and Afghanistan. What Balochistan requires is a change of perspective, away from self-interest and to aspire to a visionary political approach to tribal leadership; to shun their minor differences and to work together to achieve lasting peace and bring prosperity to the traumatised Baloch population.

There are many reasons why the current situation is as bleak as it is now, but the major cause of failure to achieve political progress is a lack of understanding and a lack of clear strategy to respond to the Pakistani establishment’s malicious and hurtful policies that are put in place to subjugate the Baloch people in place of real negotiation. Each political party and group is responding merely to their own agenda, and Islamabad is using this to its own advantage. Baloch political groups need to come up with a plan to respond to Islamabad and create a win-win situation that benefits everyone. Whether this is feasible is arguable: the real sentiments that individual players in this scenario possess, is truly, anyone’s guess. Nationalists on the one hand proudly assert their support of the oppressed Baloch, yet may only wish to keep hold of their powerbase and wealth that their feudal status confers. They accuse pro-government leaders of collaboration, yet they could be said to be as corrupt as their opponents given their refusal to step back from the tribal system that makes them who they are. Equally, those taking money from government contracts could be said to be the mirror image of their opponents. Indeed, the dividing line is often less than clear: many tribal leaders take advantage of the benefits offered by pro-government leaders despite their apparent disdain. Corruption in the Pakistani enterprise could be said to be endemic to the point where it cannot be avoided at some point without a resignation from power that both parties refuse to sanction. It will take something more than heated words from positions of privilege to effect change. What is needed in Pakistan and Balochistan is a real need to open up government to true democratic change that cannot happen under the current tribal and federal system, as selfishness is integral to running both the state and the opposition. Deeply entrenched as they are, it may be possible if the will to achieve real political change can take place. At present, this is a very remote possibility. The struggles of my people is why I wish to dedicate my life to the same goals as my family. To support our province, our people and achieve some degree of justice. But the status quo means I cannot do this alone. Not until people as courageous as Sabeen Mahmud stand with us. The lesson of East Pakistan should have been enough for most Pakistanis to stand up against injustice but I do not blame most of you, most of you are not aware of our despair. I write this, not with contempt but because I implore you to open your eyes, to heed our suffering and help build a better future.


13 Responses to “Balochistan: Another Perspective”

  1. mirGhaffar April 28, 2015 at 11:18 am #

    It is very unfortunate that we have never learnt from our mistakes, we keep repeating all blunders we committed in the past. Baluch are our brothers and patriotic pakistanis,i think we should ponder that why these son of soil have taken up arms. We should think to find ways to include them in national development. History is full of witnesses that major national big issues have been resolved through dialogue.

    Baluchistan is backward area in all aspects,their children should be educated,feelings of deprivation among baluchs need to be ended and it is time to develop province in all aspects.

    For me complete provincial autonomy is the only solution of this grave problem and equal opportunites in all national programmes. Liberation is not in any way a solution,so both sides need to sit together and resolve this issue to ensure prosperity in Baluchistan and Pakistan.

  2. Syed Abbas Shah Gillani April 28, 2015 at 12:00 pm #

    Really interesting, you are proud of people of Baluchistan… God bless you at every step in life.

  3. Ilyas April 29, 2015 at 1:46 am #

    Salutes! Thanks a lot for writing this. I really believe that the emancipation of Baloch people is the real key to the success of Pakistan as a democracy and as a nation.

  4. Tabish hazir April 29, 2015 at 7:17 am #

    although one cannot disagree with most of the historical facts that she has mentioned. I only have ONE question for her and her entire family. Madam WHAT DID YOU AND YOUR ANCESTORS DO FOR THE BETTERMENT OF BALOUCH PEOPLE. you and your family represents the exploitative class which NEVER deemed it fit either to educate or empower Balouch nation. you and your ancestors were and are ONLY interested in controlling POWER. with the track record of balouch tribal sardars do you expect the world to believe that you are GENUINELY interested in the well being of balouchs. please dont insult our intelligence Miss Mengal!

    • Mir Balach Baloch April 30, 2015 at 9:15 pm #

      Please forget for a moment the revulsion you have in your head against Baloch people and Read !!

      Let me Answer you:
      1 – She is a Baloch lady surrounded by cultural blocks, but still she wrote for the same people and is devoting her life for them.
      2 – The exploitative class which you call them lost there lives, family, resources and still stands for the Baloch.
      3 – You blame them for not empowering Baloch – Up there Historical facts do make sense to you – let me give you another one. The total term served both Mengal Sardars served in office is not equal to 3 years, because your Pakistan was/is always terrified of them developing the Baloch society.

      You spent your life, read an article and left a comment but still cannot spell “Baloch” properly yet ? – You need help Bro !!

      I have given up on you Pakistanis, no matter how educated they get still some part of them remains stuck in typical Punjabi Box !!

      May Allah help you to get out of that !!

    • Waleed Saghar June 30, 2015 at 2:23 pm #

      Nice Question, right on money!

  5. Ali Anwar April 29, 2015 at 8:59 am #

    Like father like daughter.proud of you my sister when you say ” I wish to delicate my life to same goals as my family”.

  6. Mir Balach Baloch April 30, 2015 at 9:26 pm #

    Proud of you Bibi !!

    There has been countless manipulation of Baloch society , and I pray that we don’t end up in a civil war. Nationalism, the Liberal Baloch society and our Values stand against the Massive Islamization, Mullahism and the puppets of Pakistan.

    The only way out is Unity – if we need to save our culture, identity and the roots of Chakar E Axam, we need to hold hands and struggle for our survival !!

    • Amjad June 24, 2016 at 7:33 pm #

      In world beyond 1980s there is no closed culture left on surface of earth. No nation or sub-national group can isolate her from rest of neighbouring and world. Baloch are proud nation yet its time to realise that Sardars can not impose their personal will with label of nation. Baloch surely need to stand united and look for their interests. It must be decided by populace without any pressure from opportunists of any type.

  7. ujmalik June 30, 2015 at 3:35 pm #

    My ancestors were forced to leave Balochistan in 60s called an “abadkar”, I know people who have been positively contributing to the Baloch people as Doctors and Academics but were gunned down just because they weren’t Baloch! To this day dozens of “poorest of poor” non-Baloch are brazenly killed in Balochistan just after checking their CNIC. But i cannot recall a single Baloch leader including her father standing up for any of them. In fact people like Senator Sana have gone to the extent of rationalising all this!

    Probably it is high time to stop these double standards and while we are at it can please someone finally help me understand how your family and other Sardar families being from area with so much poverty are able to live such a prosperous life in what very often is another country (with a substantially stronger currency)?

  8. Sufian July 1, 2015 at 12:30 pm #

    Good One…

  9. Malik Rizwan Ul Haque July 24, 2015 at 7:37 am #

    Very Ironic and Very Sad .. that we have such families in power in politics who even does not consider them Pakistani ….. Balochistan and a comman man of Pakistan is suffering only because of Nawabs like you .. how they become Nawabs ..they were not freedom fighters they were ass kissers of British and traitors to this muslim nations ..that’s how they got such big Lands and kingdoms….and same is their generations.. Snake gives birth to snakes .. you all are traitors.. and the only solution to this problem of whole pakistan is elimination of all Jagirdars and Nawabs.. such people should be hanged in streets….Musharraf was 100% right about you people…

  10. Amjad January 1, 2016 at 10:50 am #

    I been student of ethnicity and federalism in Pakistan for my M.Phil course. (* just as reference to mention am not talking from hallucinations or barrowed ideas)

    Am always advocate of people’s power and freedoms. I have great regards for Akhtar Mengal, truly was happy to see him back in Pakistan. Many times I do remember Mr Akbar khan Bugti for his stance of many issues.

    There no single responsible organisation or person who messed in Balochistan but unfortunately everyone made mistakes from my favorite politician Jinnah to Sharif.
    On one side where Balochistan history is being mixed with history of Kalat state and resistance against Pakistan by Khan Kareem Khan while went on self-excile in Afghanistan. While on otherside all good or bad Baloch sardars are abusing people by gaining benefits from government and depriving people from very basic rights of freedom and liberty within tribes.
    Its more funny to find educated people of Balochistan still insisting to government to bribe undemocratic and slightly exploiting system of tribal Sardars by negotiating only with them.
    Practically blunders were initially made by Pakistani federal governments officers by feeding Sardars with different royalties beyond what was their personal or tribal share on resources just to keep their own personal gains.
    Instead promotion of education, local government institutions and development of infrastructures money was given to tribal Sardars who are non-elected patriarchal representatives which are holding powers successfully because they successfully blocked promotion of democratic values and fairness in the society. Question will be simple how many Sardars claim their right to represent people based on general suffrage? How many tribes elected or selected either way a new family person away from Sardar families and cousins? Without resolving issues Balochistan can not move forward.
    On other side Pakistan central government made many blunders which created resentments and sense of sever deprivations in Baloch people. Its time to compensate those blunders and Balochistan must be given priority especially in distribution of resources. Baloch people must have major portion of resources and their children must get access to any natural resource first than rest of Pakistan. People instead Sardars must be powered and engaged. All Sardars including ones who are in self excile must be given due respect and consideration while making progress. All Sardars must be given chance to lead their people fairly and their concerns if possible all concerns must be accommodated fairly.
    Last i would say that people like Akhtar Mengal deserve more respect and leading role in Pakistan’s national politics. Media is surely biased and unfair towards Balochistan. There are good changes in recent yet those are far far less than what we all required to do in Balochistan. Such changes required baloch leaders and people to play their positive role without waiting for central governments to help them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: